Friday, October 8, 2010

Book Review: "Catalyst" by Anne McCafery and Elizabeth Ann Scarborough

Catalyst is a science fiction/fantasy book written by two authors, both award winners in their own right. The main author many people will probably recognize from her award winning series Dragon Riders of Pern. That is correct, I am talking about Anne McCafrey. The co-author - another award winner though maybe not as famous (yet?) - Elizabeth Ann Scarborough has already won the Hugo award for science fiction.

There are many twist and turns in this book. One aspect I thought was really unique about this book was the third person narration by a highly intelligent, sentient cat. The book's perspective shifts subtly throughout the book, but maintains the same narrator throughout.

Pros: I would say that the first pro of this book was the thorough and detailed universe it takes place in. Second, the realalistic and all-too-true depiction of political networks and their use of influence throughout the universe echoes modern political discourse.

Cons: Though it is partially explained by the universe it takes place in, the first con of Catalyst is narrative implausibility. There are a few contradictory elements, and these inconsistencies threaten verisimilitude. Secondly, I think that though the romance of the book is not very important, they could have included more background details, which would have enhanced the book's story a bit.

No comments:

Post a Comment